Home › The Public Scorecard › Chapter 50

The Public Scorecard

Chapter 50Business: The Public Business Scorecard

8,969 words · Mike Seiler · Owen Sound, Ontario

Open in the reader →

Vote on the proposals, hear the audio, read the reviews, search the whole plan.

In this chapter

50.1 Purpose
50.2 Business Success Is Not Government Ownership
50.3 Government Is Referee and Infrastructure Provider
50.4 Business Scorecard Headline Measures
50.5 City-Controlled Versus Economic Context
50.6 Start-Up Desk
50.7 One Starting Point
50.8 One Starting Point Does Not Mean One Approval
50.9 Start-Up Desk Intake
50.10 Business Inquiry Categories
50.11 Before You Sign
50.12 Before You Sign Is Not Legal Advice
50.13 Before You Sign Measure
50.14 Avoided Mistake
50.15 No Fake "Business Saved" Dollar
50.16 Ten-Business-Day Standard
50.17 Ten Days Does Not Mean Everything Approved
50.18 Eligible Files
50.19 Clock Start
50.20 Complete Information
50.21 Clock Stop
50.22 Clock Pause
50.23 No Hidden Pause
50.24 Standard Performance
50.25 Fee Waiver
50.26 Fee Waiver Count
50.27 Fee Waiver Is Accountability
50.28 No Unsafe Approval Incentive
50.29 No Automatic Waiver Outside Policy
50.30 Business Service Clarity
50.31 Approval Is Not Satisfaction
50.32 Business Approval Rate
50.33 Early No
50.34 Red Tape Log
50.35 What Belongs in the Red Tape Log
50.36 What Does Not Automatically Belong
50.37 Barrier Status
50.38 Explain Retained Rules
50.39 Remove What Is Unnecessary
50.40 Duplicate Information
50.41 Form Reduction
50.42 Process Steps
50.43 Fewer Steps Can Be Better
50.44 Red Tape Time Savings
50.45 Business Application Rework
50.46 Resident Error May Be Design Error
50.47 City Error
50.48 Business Openings
50.49 Opening Definition
50.50 No Imaginary Comprehensive Registry
50.51 Data Source
50.52 Business Closures
50.53 Closure Is Not Always Failure
50.54 Business Relocation
50.55 Expansion
50.56 No "Jobs Created" Without Evidence
50.57 Employment Data
50.58 City-Controlled Employment
50.59 Business Survival
50.60 Survival Is Context
50.61 Commercial Vacancy
50.62 Outside Downtown
50.63 Business Geography
50.64 No Business Heatmap of Weakness
50.65 Business Investment
50.66 Permit Value
50.67 Public Investment Separate
50.68 Investment Is Not Profit
50.69 Economic Impact
50.70 No Promotional Economics in the Scorecard
50.71 Business Satisfaction
50.72 Core Municipal Questions
50.73 Do Not Ask Business Owners to Grade the Mayor
50.74 Anonymous Feedback
50.75 No Retaliation
50.76 Survey Sample
50.77 Small Sample
50.78 Business Roundtables
50.79 No Invitation Club
50.80 Established Businesses
50.81 Succession
50.82 Home-Based Business
50.83 Home-Based Business Is Still Business
50.84 Neighbourhood Compatibility
50.85 Manufacturing and Industrial Business
50.86 Industrial Land
50.87 Servicing Constraint
50.88 Infrastructure Capacity Is Not a Business Approval
50.89 Business Site Readiness
50.90 No "Shovel Ready" Without Evidence
50.91 Tourism Business
50.92 Visitor Spending
50.93 Events and Business
50.94 Shop Local
50.95 Shop Local Is Voluntary
50.96 Shopper Choice Remains
50.97 Local Definition
50.98 Local Business Is Not Always Locally Owned
50.99 Directory
50.100 Directory Basic Listing
50.101 No Paid Basic Ranking
50.102 Sponsored Promotion
50.103 Directory Accuracy
50.104 Stale Listings
50.105 Directory Is Not Endorsement
50.106 Search Fairness
50.107 Open Standards
50.108 map.ca Firewall
50.109 No Forced Platform
50.110 Payment Education
50.111 No Permanent Fee Claim
50.112 Business Chooses Payment Method
50.113 Customer Chooses Payment Method
50.114 No Payment Shaming
50.115 Interac-Focused Pilot
50.116 No Claimed Savings Without Business Evidence
50.117 Penny
50.118 Penny Is Not Legal Tender
50.119 Penny Funding
50.120 No Unfunded Penny
50.121 Penny Liability
50.122 Redemption Rate
50.123 Breakage
50.124 Penny Cost
50.125 Penny Benefit
50.126 Penny Sales Attribution
50.127 Customer Privacy
50.128 Anonymous or Minimal Participation
50.129 No Political Profile
50.130 Fraud Control
50.131 Merchant Abuse
50.132 Consumer Protection
50.133 Expiry
50.134 Wind-Down
50.135 Honour Legitimate Balances
50.136 Penny Decision Gate
50.137 Local Delivery
50.138 Existing Providers First
50.139 Gap Definition
50.140 Delivery Pilot
50.141 Delivery Measures
50.142 Cost per Delivery
50.143 Subsidy per Delivery
50.144 No "Free Delivery"
50.145 Delivery Is Not Infrastructure Necessarily
50.146 Private Operator Preference
50.147 Delivery Competition
50.148 Delivery Exit
50.149 Community Pooling
50.150 Pooling Starts Narrow
50.151 Pooling Category
50.152 Voluntary Participation
50.153 Pooling Baseline
50.154 Pooling Saving
50.155 Shipping Counts
50.156 Administration Counts
50.157 Inventory Risk
50.158 Pre-Order Model
50.159 Canadian Suppliers
50.160 Canadian Does Not Automatically Mean Cheapest
50.161 Foreign Supply Remains Possible
50.162 Supplier Diversity
50.163 No Supplier Favouritism
50.164 Pooling Procurement Rules
50.165 City as Facilitator
50.166 Independent Cooperative
50.167 Final Pooling Status
50.168 Enthusiast Economy
50.169 Enthusiast Does Not Mean Hobby Only
50.170 Community Reveals the Categories
50.171 Gap Mapping
50.172 Gap Is Opportunity, Not City Mandate
50.173 Enthusiast Directory
50.174 Repair Economy
50.175 Repair Business Count
50.176 Repair Capacity
50.177 No Self-Sufficiency Score
50.178 Maker Economy
50.179 City-Owned Maker Space
50.180 Partnership Before Program
50.181 Events
50.182 Training
50.183 Youth
50.184 No Free Labour for Businesses
50.185 Entrepreneurship Education
50.186 Local Procurement
50.187 Vendor Gateway
50.188 Vendor Count
50.189 Local Vendor Participation
50.190 No Local Win Quota by Default
50.191 Local Award Share
50.192 Canadian Award Share
50.193 Award Share Is Not Procurement Quality
50.194 Procurement Competition
50.195 One Bid
50.196 One Bid Is Not Automatically Corruption
50.197 Small Contract Access
50.198 No Artificial Contract Splitting
50.199 Quick Quote
50.200 Quick Does Not Mean Closed Club
50.201 Procurement Forecast
50.202 Forecast Is Not Promise
50.203 Vendor Education
50.204 Do Not Coach One Bidder Privately
50.205 Bid Complexity
50.206 Safety and Insurance Remain
50.207 Repair Before Replace
50.208 Repair Saving
50.209 Canadian Capacity Screen
50.210 Canadian Is One Factor
50.211 Supplier Concentration
50.212 Local Supplier Development
50.213 Procurement Feedback
50.214 Bidder Feedback
50.215 Complaint Process
50.216 No Campaign Procurement
50.217 No Opponent Penalty
50.218 Business Incentives
50.219 Incentive Types
50.220 Complete Public Contribution
50.221 Incentive Approval
50.222 Incentive Completion
50.223 Clawback
50.224 No Favourite Business
50.225 Incentive Evaluation
50.226 Public Land
50.227 Discounted Land
50.228 Jobs Commitment
50.229 No Job Estimate as Job Delivered
50.230 Privacy
50.231 Commercial Development
50.232 Approved Commercial Space Is Not Operating Business
50.233 Occupancy
50.234 Development Processing Time
50.235 City-Controlled Delay
50.236 Applicant Delay
50.237 Outside Agency
50.238 One Business File
50.239 File Owner
50.240 No Mayor Case Manager
50.241 Equal Queue
50.242 Major Employer
50.243 Economic Emergency
50.244 Business Retention
50.245 Retention Is Hard to Attribute
50.246 Business Recruitment
50.247 Announcement Is Not Arrival
50.248 Signed Agreement Is Not Operating
50.249 Open for Business
50.250 Major Employer Departure
50.251 No Mayor Blame for Every Closure
50.252 No Mayor Credit for Every Opening
50.253 Business Support Partners
50.254 Partnership Before Program
50.255 Do Not Duplicate Advice
50.256 Municipal Specialty
50.257 Referral Quality
50.258 Partner Capacity
50.259 Shared Business Desk
50.260 No Wrong Government
50.261 Planning Handoff
50.262 Business Education
50.263 Attendance Is Not Business Creation
50.264 Useful Outcome
50.265 Mentorship
50.266 Volunteer Mentors
50.267 No Investor Matching Guarantee
50.268 Business Financing
50.269 Federal and Provincial Programs
50.270 Program Date
50.271 Stale Grant
50.272 Grant Application Help
50.273 Business Data
50.274 Directory Data
50.275 Financial Data
50.276 Customer Data
50.277 Purchase History
50.278 Aggregation
50.279 No Political Profiling
50.280 Business Contact Lists
50.281 Commercial Confidentiality
50.282 Open Books Still Apply to Public Money
50.283 Privacy Is Not Secrecy for Subsidy
50.284 Business Map
50.285 No Performance Heatmap
50.286 Hours and Status
50.287 Public Correction
50.288 Digital Independence
50.289 Export
50.290 No Platform Lock-In
50.291 AI in Business Navigation
50.292 AI Accuracy
50.293 No AI Permit Approval by Default
50.294 Human Escalation
50.295 AI Source
50.296 Wrong Answer
50.297 Commercial Advice Boundary
50.298 Business Resilience
50.299 Supplier Risk
50.300 Canadian Capacity
50.301 Do Not Count Search Result as Supplier Conversion
50.302 Supplier Adoption
50.303 Repairability
50.304 Emergency Business Continuity
50.305 City Does Not Guarantee Continuity
50.306 Public Infrastructure Reliability
50.307 Construction Impact
50.308 Advance Notice
50.309 Access Plan
50.310 Construction Delay
50.311 Business Feedback After Construction
50.312 No Automatic Compensation
50.313 Downtown Business
50.314 Upper Floors
50.315 Enthusiast Economy
50.316 Tourism
50.317 Youth Entrepreneurship
50.318 Canadian Procurement
50.319 Avoid Double Counting
50.320 Business Scorecard Table
50.321 Start-Up Desk Table
50.322 Red Tape Table
50.323 Business Activity Table
50.324 Procurement Access Table
50.325 Shop Local Table
50.326 Penny Table
50.327 Pooling Table
50.328 Delivery Table
50.329 Canadian Capacity Table
50.330 Traffic Lights
50.331 Green Business Openings
50.332 Red Closure Rate
50.333 City-Controlled Metrics Receive Status
50.334 External Context May Use Trend Only
50.335 Anti-Gaming Rule One
50.336 Anti-Gaming Rule Two
50.337 Anti-Gaming Rule Three
50.338 Anti-Gaming Rule Four
50.339 Anti-Gaming Rule Five
50.340 Anti-Gaming Rule Six
50.341 Anti-Gaming Rule Seven
50.342 Anti-Gaming Rule Eight
50.343 Anti-Gaming Rule Nine
50.344 Anti-Gaming Rule Ten
50.345 Anti-Gaming Rule Eleven
50.346 Anti-Gaming Rule Twelve
50.347 Anti-Gaming Rule Thirteen
50.348 Anti-Gaming Rule Fourteen
50.349 Anti-Gaming Rule Fifteen
50.350 Anti-Gaming Rule Sixteen
50.351 Anti-Gaming Rule Seventeen
50.352 Anti-Gaming Rule Eighteen
50.353 Anti-Gaming Rule Nineteen
50.354 Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty
50.355 Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty-One
50.356 Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty-Two
50.357 Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty-Three
50.358 Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty-Four
50.359 Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty-Five
50.360 Baseline
50.361 Unknown Baseline
50.362 No Historical Reconstruction From Anecdote
50.363 Year One Objective
50.364 Year Two Objective
50.365 Year Three Objective
50.366 Year Four Objective
50.367 Four-Year Core Measures
50.368 Business Openings Four-Year Trend
50.369 Business Closures Four-Year Trend
50.370 Net Business Count
50.371 A Few Strong Employers
50.372 Small Business Still Matters
50.373 Home Business Still Matters
50.374 Repair Business Still Matters
50.375 Entrepreneurship Is Not Only Start-Ups
50.376 Four-Year Business Audit
50.377 Name the Biggest Municipal Business Improvement
50.378 Name the Biggest Municipal Business Failure
50.379 Name the Most Common Start-Up Barrier
50.380 Name the Largest Red-Tape Reform
50.381 Name a Rule That Was Reviewed and Kept
50.382 Name the Best Procurement Improvement
50.383 Name the Shop Local Program That Worked Best
50.384 Name a Shop Local Program That Was Stopped
50.385 Name the Penny Result
50.386 Name the Delivery Result
50.387 Name the Pooling Result
50.388 Name the Canadian Capacity Result
50.389 Name the Best Enthusiast-Economy Opportunity
50.390 Name the Biggest Business Constraint the City Could Not Solve
50.391 Start-Up Desk Test
50.392 Before You Sign Test
50.393 Red Tape Test
50.394 Procurement Test
50.395 Shop Local Test
50.396 Penny Test
50.397 Delivery Test
50.398 Pooling Test
50.399 Canadian Capacity Test
50.400 Enthusiast Economy Test
50.401 Business Activity Test
50.402 Business Satisfaction Test
50.403 Fairness Test
50.404 Privacy Test
50.405 Institution Test
50.406 What Success Looks Like
50.407 What Failure Looks Like
50.408 The Business Scorecard Commitment

A municipality can claim to be:

open for business

while entrepreneurs still encounter:

unclear rules;
repeated referrals;
unexpected requirements;
long municipal delays;
contradictory answers;
applications nobody clearly owns;
incentives they discover too late;
permits they did not know they needed;
infrastructure limitations identified after money has already been spent.

The Business Scorecard should therefore begin with a narrower and more defensible question:

Is it easier to understand and do lawful business in Owen Sound than it was four years ago?

That does not mean:

every business succeeds;
every application is approved;
every storefront remains open;
City Hall controls the economy.

It means municipal government should make its own part:

understandable;
predictable;
timely;
fair;
accessible.

The original initiative framework proposes a Start-Up Desk, Shop Local tools, an Interac-focused payment initiative, the Penny reward concept, local delivery, pooled purchasing and increased access to Canadian suppliers.

The Business Scorecard should determine which of those ideas actually work.

The principle is:

Measure municipal friction first. Measure business activity second. Never claim that City Hall created an entrepreneur's success.

50.1Purpose

The Business Scorecard should answer:

Can an entrepreneur understand what the City requires?

Can they find the right municipal contact?

Do they receive a meaningful answer within the adopted service standard?

Are requirements identified early?

Are municipal processing times improving?

Are unnecessary steps being removed?

Can local suppliers compete fairly for City work?

Are Shop Local programs producing measurable value?

Does the Penny produce more benefit than cost?

Does local delivery solve a real gap?

Does pooled purchasing save participating businesses money?

Are Canadian supplier alternatives becoming easier to find?

Is the Enthusiast Economy producing actual activity?

Are businesses opening, expanding and closing?

What part of those outcomes can reasonably be connected to municipal action?

That is the business record.

50.2Business Success Is Not Government Ownership

A healthy municipal business strategy does not mean:

City Hall runs commerce.

Private businesses:

decide what to sell;
hire employees;
set prices;
take risks;
compete;
succeed;
fail.

The City should improve the environment in which lawful business occurs.

50.3Government Is Referee and Infrastructure Provider

Municipal government's role may include:

planning;
permits;
inspections;
roads;
public realm;
information;
procurement;
economic-development support;
partnerships.

It should not become:

preferred retailer;
investment adviser;
commercial gatekeeper.

50.4Business Scorecard Headline Measures

A first-page dashboard could include:

Start-Up Desk requests.
Meaningful response within service standard.
Ten-business-day standard performance where adopted.
Fee waivers triggered by missed municipal standard.
Before You Sign consultations.
Municipal process barriers identified.
Barriers removed or simplified.
Business applications completed.
Business openings.
Business closures.
Business expansions.
Commercial vacancy.
Business satisfaction with municipal service.
Local Vendor Gateway participation.
Local supplier bid participation.
Procurement competition.
Shop Local directory participation.
Penny participation and financial status.
Local delivery status.
Community Pooling results.
Canadian supplier alternatives identified.
Repair and maker economy activity.
Business-support referrals.
Major commercial investment.
Municipal incentives.
Business-related servicing constraints.
Major unresolved municipal business barriers.

That is enough for the headline.

50.5City-Controlled Versus Economic Context

Every business measure should be placed into one of three categories.

City Controlled

Examples:

municipal service time;
municipal requirements;
procurement access;
municipal fees;
City incentives.

Shared

Examples:

regional economic development;
infrastructure;
workforce initiatives;
transportation.

External Context

Examples:

interest rates;
national economy;
exchange rates;
provincial regulation;
consumer demand.

Do not hold City Hall responsible for what it cannot control.

Do not allow City Hall to claim credit for it either.

50.6Start-Up Desk

The Start-Up Desk should be one of the strongest business-service measures.

Its purpose is not:

convince people to start businesses.

Its purpose is:

help a person with a serious business idea understand the municipal path.

50.7One Starting Point

A business owner should be able to begin with:

one contact;
one intake;
one clear municipal pathway.

50.8One Starting Point Does Not Mean One Approval

A business may still require:

planning;
building;
fire;
licensing;
public health or other external review.

One window means:

coordinated navigation.

Not:

elimination of lawful requirements.

50.9Start-Up Desk Intake

Track:

inquiries;
serious project consultations;
formal municipal files.

Do not count every casual question as a:

business started.

50.10Business Inquiry Categories

Useful categories may include:

new storefront;
home-based business;
restaurant or food use;
professional service;
manufacturing;
tourism;
repair;
entertainment;
mixed-use;
other.

Use categories that reflect actual local demand.

50.11Before You Sign

The Before You Sign service should help prospective tenants or buyers understand obvious municipal constraints before:

lease;
purchase;
renovation commitment.

50.12Before You Sign Is Not Legal Advice

The City should explain:

municipal requirements.

It should not replace:

lawyer;
accountant;
engineer;
building professional.

50.13Before You Sign Measure

Track:

consultations;
whether municipal requirements were identified;
whether serious barriers were discovered early.

50.14Avoided Mistake

A valuable result may be:

The entrepreneur did not sign a lease for a location that could not reasonably support the proposed use.

That is not:

business failure.

It may be excellent municipal service.

50.15No Fake "Business Saved" Dollar

Do not claim:

We saved the entrepreneur $100,000

unless evidence supports that amount.

Better:

A material municipal issue was identified before lease commitment.

50.16Ten-Business-Day Standard

Where Council adopts the proposed ten-business-day business-response standard:

Define precisely what it means.

50.17Ten Days Does Not Mean Everything Approved

The standard should mean the adopted municipal milestone, such as:

consolidated municipal requirements;
formal answer;
clear next status;

not necessarily:

building open for business.

50.18Eligible Files

Define which business inquiries qualify.

50.19Clock Start

Define when the ten-business-day period starts.

50.20Complete Information

If information is required before the clock begins:

Tell the applicant exactly what is missing.

50.21Clock Stop

Define the municipal milestone that satisfies the standard.

50.22Clock Pause

If legitimate:

Use clear pause categories.

50.23No Hidden Pause

Do not label a file:

awaiting applicant

to hide municipal delay.

50.24Standard Performance

Publish:

eligible files

standard met

standard missed

percentage met

median City-controlled time

50.25Fee Waiver

Where an adopted guarantee includes an eligible municipal fee waiver for failure to meet the defined standard:

Track it.

50.26Fee Waiver Count

Publish:

number;
value.

50.27Fee Waiver Is Accountability

It should not be treated as:

punishment of staff.

It is a City-level consequence for missing an adopted service commitment.

50.28No Unsafe Approval Incentive

The fee consequence must never pressure professional staff to:

skip;
weaken;

lawful review.

50.29No Automatic Waiver Outside Policy

Apply the policy consistently.

Not according to:

personal relationship;
mayoral intervention.

50.30Business Service Clarity

Survey Start-Up Desk users.

Possible questions:

Did you know what the City required?

Did you know who owned your file?

Did you know the next step?

Did you know the likely municipal fees?

Did different City departments give consistent guidance?

50.31Approval Is Not Satisfaction

A business may receive:

It can still receive excellent service.

Measure:

clarity;
consistency;
timeliness.

50.32Business Approval Rate

Do not use:

percentage approved

as the primary service score.

A high approval rate can simply mean:

easier applications;
self-selection.

50.33Early No

A clear early no can save:

time;
money;
conflict.

50.34Red Tape Log

Maintain a public Red Tape Log.

50.35What Belongs in the Red Tape Log

A recurring municipal requirement that may be:

unnecessary;
duplicative;
outdated;
confusing.

50.36What Does Not Automatically Belong

A requirement is not red tape simply because an applicant dislikes it.

Examples may include legitimate:

fire;
accessibility;
environmental;
building;

requirements.

50.37Barrier Status

Possible categories:

Identified

Under Review

Removed

Simplified

Retained

Outside City Authority

50.38Explain Retained Rules

If a barrier is retained:

Explain:

public purpose.

That may increase respect even where businesses disagree.

50.39Remove What Is Unnecessary

If the City cannot explain the public purpose:

Review whether the requirement should remain.

50.40Duplicate Information

Track recurring instances where businesses provide the same information repeatedly to municipal departments.

Reduce where lawful.

50.41Form Reduction

Measure significant:

fields removed;
forms consolidated.

Do not count cosmetic form edits as major regulatory reform.

50.42Process Steps

For selected common business paths:

Track the number of municipal process stages.

50.43Fewer Steps Can Be Better

Only if:

safety;
legal compliance;

remain.

50.44Red Tape Time Savings

Where actual workflow data supports it:

Measure reduced processing time.

Do not invent dollar savings.

50.45Business Application Rework

Track files returned because of:

missing information;
incorrect form;
City instruction error.

50.46Resident Error May Be Design Error

If many applicants make the same mistake:

Improve the instruction.

50.47City Error

If City guidance caused rework:

Correct the process.

50.48Business Openings

Track new business openings where the data can be reasonably verified.

50.49Opening Definition

Define what counts.

Possible:

a business begins operating at a physical Owen Sound location or registers under an applicable local process.

Use actual data sources available.

50.50No Imaginary Comprehensive Registry

The City may not know every:

sole proprietor;
online business;
home business.

Be honest about coverage.

50.51Data Source

Possible sources may include:

municipal licences where applicable;
permits;
business directory updates;
voluntary business information.

Do not claim completeness without evidence.

50.52Business Closures

Track where reliably known.

50.53Closure Is Not Always Failure

A business may close because:

retirement;
sale;
relocation;
owner choice;
poor market performance.

Do not infer cause.

50.54Business Relocation

Where possible distinguish:

Opened new to Owen Sound

Relocated within Owen Sound

Expanded

Closed

50.55Expansion

Business expansion may be a stronger economic indicator than business count alone.

Possible measures:

larger premises;
permit investment;
added operating location.

Use reliable evidence.

50.56No "Jobs Created" Without Evidence

Do not claim:

City policy created 300 jobs

simply because businesses expanded during the term.

50.57Employment Data

Use external employment data as context.

Label source and geography.

50.58City-Controlled Employment

Municipal employment belongs to:

workforce;
finance.

Do not use City hiring to inflate private-sector business growth.

50.59Business Survival

Where reliable:

Track one-, two- or three-year survival of businesses entering a voluntary municipal support program.

50.60Survival Is Context

Do not claim:

The Start-Up Desk kept 85% alive.

Many other variables determine business survival.

50.61Commercial Vacancy

Cross-reference Section 48.

Do not count the same vacancy measure twice in the final city-wide summary.

50.62Outside Downtown

The Business Scorecard should also examine commercial and industrial activity outside downtown.

50.63Business Geography

Possible broad areas:

downtown;
highway commercial;
industrial;
neighbourhood;
home-based.

Do not create unnecessarily detailed business surveillance.

50.64No Business Heatmap of Weakness

Do not publicly identify:

struggling businesses

through private financial data.

50.65Business Investment

Track meaningful:

commercial;
industrial;

permit activity.

50.66Permit Value

Use the official permit or construction-value terminology.

It is not automatically equal to:

actual investment.

50.67Public Investment Separate

Do not combine:

private investment;
municipal spending;

into one number without breakdown.

50.68Investment Is Not Profit

A business spending $2 million on renovation does not mean:

it earned $2 million.

Obvious, but important.

50.69Economic Impact

Do not publish multipliers unless methodology is credible.

50.70No Promotional Economics in the Scorecard

The business dashboard is not a chamber-of-commerce advertisement.

It is a governance tool.

50.71Business Satisfaction

Use an annual or periodic business survey.

50.72Core Municipal Questions

Ask:

Are municipal requirements understandable?

Is communication timely?

Do departments provide consistent information?

Is the public realm working?

Is parking or loading a material municipal barrier?

Is procurement accessible?

What is the largest City-controlled barrier?

50.73Do Not Ask Business Owners to Grade the Mayor

Keep political support separate.

50.74Anonymous Feedback

Allow anonymity where practical.

50.75No Retaliation

Critical businesses receive the same:

permits;
inspections;
procurement opportunity;

as supporters.

50.76Survey Sample

Publish:

response count;
limitations.

50.77Small Sample

Do not say:

90% of Owen Sound businesses support the program

if:

27 businesses responded.

Say:

Among 27 respondents...

50.78Business Roundtables

Roundtables can provide qualitative evidence.

They do not replace:

broad measurement.

50.79No Invitation Club

Rotate participation.

Allow open routes to contribute.

50.80Established Businesses

Do not focus only on start-ups.

Existing businesses may face:

expansion;
succession;
renovation;
regulatory;

issues.

50.81Succession

Business succession can be an important local issue.

The City can:

connect;
inform.

It should not provide individualized financial advice beyond its competence.

50.82Home-Based Business

Measure whether municipal guidance is clear.

50.83Home-Based Business Is Still Business

Do not require a storefront to count legitimate economic activity where the business model does not need one.

50.84Neighbourhood Compatibility

Home-based business still follows lawful:

land-use;
nuisance;

rules.

50.85Manufacturing and Industrial Business

Their needs can differ significantly.

Possible municipal issues:

servicing;
transportation;
land;
permits.

50.86Industrial Land

Track broad:

available;
serviced;
constrained;

land where appropriate.

Do not claim private parcels are publicly available without owner participation.

50.87Servicing Constraint

Cross-reference Infrastructure.

50.88Infrastructure Capacity Is Not a Business Approval

Same principle as housing.

50.89Business Site Readiness

For public economic-development sites:

Clearly distinguish:

Available

Serviced

Partially Serviced

Requires Study

Not Available

50.90No "Shovel Ready" Without Evidence

Avoid the phrase unless:

land;
servicing;
approvals;

really support it.

50.91Tourism Business

Tourism activity should be measured within the proper regional and municipal context.

50.92Visitor Spending

Do not attribute regional tourism spending entirely to Owen Sound businesses.

50.93Events and Business

Cross-reference Section 48.

Do not claim an event's attendance equals sales.

50.94Shop Local

The original initiative framework proposes a Shop Local system incorporating Interac-based payment habits, a Penny reward, local delivery and pooled purchasing.

Each component should stand or fall on evidence.

50.95Shop Local Is Voluntary

No business should be required to:

join;
promote;

a municipal Shop Local program to receive normal City service.

50.96Shopper Choice Remains

Residents may buy from:

local;
regional;
national;
international;

businesses.

Government may encourage local economic resilience.

It should not police household purchases.

50.97Local Definition

Define what:

local business

means for each program.

Possible considerations:

physical Owen Sound location;
locally owned;
locally operated;
regional.

Do not change definition opportunistically.

50.98Local Business Is Not Always Locally Owned

A national chain location may employ local people.

A locally owned online business may have no storefront.

Be precise.

50.99Directory

A public business directory can help residents find local offerings.

50.100Directory Basic Listing

Basic participation should be:

accessible;
neutral.

50.101No Paid Basic Ranking

Do not allow ordinary municipal directory placement to become:

pay to appear first.

50.102Sponsored Promotion

If any paid promotional feature exists:

It must be:

clearly labelled;
separated from neutral basic listings.

But the City should first ask whether it needs to sell advertising at all.

50.103Directory Accuracy

Businesses should be able to correct:

hours;
address;
services.

50.104Stale Listings

Track stale or closed business listings.

50.105Directory Is Not Endorsement

Listing means:

included under neutral criteria.

Not:

City guarantees the business.

50.106Search Fairness

Search should not favour:

political supporter;
friend;
paying basic member.

50.107Open Standards

Where possible:

Make directory data portable and reusable under appropriate rules.

50.108map.ca Firewall

If map.ca provides technology:

It must follow the same independent governance, conflict and procurement rules established earlier.

50.109No Forced Platform

Businesses should not be required to use:

map.ca;
any private platform;

to appear in basic municipal information.

50.110Payment Education

If the City provides information about lower-cost payment options:

It should use current evidence.

50.111No Permanent Fee Claim

Payment-processing costs change.

Do not hard-code outdated claims.

50.112Business Chooses Payment Method

The City can educate.

The business decides.

50.113Customer Chooses Payment Method

Where the business accepts multiple forms:

The customer decides.

50.114No Payment Shaming

Do not shame residents for using:

credit;
debit;
cash;

where lawfully accepted.

50.115Interac-Focused Pilot

If a voluntary debit-focused initiative proceeds:

Measure:

participating businesses;
participation cost;
actual business feedback.

50.116No Claimed Savings Without Business Evidence

Do not calculate:

local businesses saved $1 million

based solely on a generic transaction-fee assumption.

50.117Penny

The Penny concept must remain:

a voluntary loyalty or reward mechanism.

Not currency.

50.118Penny Is Not Legal Tender

Do not market it as:

money;
municipal currency;
replacement for Canadian dollars.

50.119Penny Funding

Before launch:

Identify exactly who funds the reward.

Possible:

participating business;
sponsor;
promotional budget;
other lawful source.

50.120No Unfunded Penny

Do not issue rewards that have no real redemption funding.

50.121Penny Liability

If unredeemed rewards create an accounting liability:

Track it.

50.122Redemption Rate

Possible measure:

Penny Redemption Rate = Rewards Redeemed ÷ Rewards Issued

Define by value and possibly number.

50.123Breakage

Unredeemed rewards must be treated according to the program's lawful accounting rules.

Do not treat unused balances as hidden profit without transparency.

50.124Penny Cost

Publish:

technology;
administration;
fraud;
marketing;
rewards funded.

50.125Penny Benefit

Possible evidence:

participating businesses;
repeat participation;
business feedback;
redemption.

Do not invent sales effects.

50.126Penny Sales Attribution

Do not say:

The Penny generated $5 million in spending

unless transaction evidence and methodology support it.

50.127Customer Privacy

Do not require the Penny to become:

behavioural tracking;
purchase-history profiling.

50.128Anonymous or Minimal Participation

Where technically feasible:

Use minimal personal data.

50.129No Political Profile

Penny participation must never connect to:

voting;
civic opinion;
campaign support.

50.130Fraud Control

Reward systems can be abused.

Track:

confirmed fraud;
correction;
loss;

at an appropriate level.

50.131Merchant Abuse

Rules should prohibit artificial transactions created simply to generate rewards.

50.132Consumer Protection

Program rules must be understandable.

50.133Expiry

If rewards expire:

Tell participants clearly.

50.134Wind-Down

Before launch:

Define how the system ends.

50.135Honour Legitimate Balances

If the program closes:

Provide a fair redemption or wind-down process.

50.136Penny Decision Gate

Possible final outcomes:

Scale

Maintain Limited

Transfer to Independent Operator

Modify

Stop

No automatic permanence.

50.137Local Delivery

The source plan also contemplates a local delivery function.

The Scorecard should first answer:

Is there a real market gap?

50.138Existing Providers First

Before the City supports delivery:

Identify existing:

courier;
taxi;
delivery;
logistics;

options.

Do not duplicate a functioning private service.

50.139Gap Definition

A gap might involve:

cost;
geographic coverage;
small-business access;
accessibility.

Prove it.

50.140Delivery Pilot

If justified:

Start small.

50.141Delivery Measures

Possible:

participating businesses;
deliveries;
cost per delivery;
customer charge;
City subsidy;
failed deliveries;
delivery time.

50.142Cost per Delivery

Use complete cost.

50.143Subsidy per Delivery

If City-supported:

Show it.

50.144No "Free Delivery"

If public money pays:

Say:

no charge to user

rather than:

free.

50.145Delivery Is Not Infrastructure Necessarily

The City should not buy a vehicle fleet until evidence justifies it.

50.146Private Operator Preference

If a private or nonprofit operator can sustainably provide the service:

That may be preferable.

50.147Delivery Competition

Do not create a subsidized municipal service that unfairly competes with existing local providers without a clear public-interest case.

50.148Delivery Exit

If the pilot cannot become sustainable or justified:

Stop.

50.149Community Pooling

The original plan proposes pooled purchases from Canadian suppliers to improve local-business buying power.

This requires careful measurement.

50.150Pooling Starts Narrow

Test one or a few categories.

Do not build a municipal wholesale empire.

50.151Pooling Category

Choose goods where:

multiple local businesses have common need;
volume purchasing may matter.

50.152Voluntary Participation

No business is forced into a pool.

50.153Pooling Baseline

Before claiming savings:

Record normal market price for a comparable purchase.

50.154Pooling Saving

Possible measure:

Verified Participant Saving = Comparable Baseline Purchase Cost - Pooled Delivered Cost - Allocated Program Cost

Use defensible methodology.

50.155Shipping Counts

A lower unit price with higher freight may not be a saving.

50.156Administration Counts

Staff time and technology count.

50.157Inventory Risk

Do not make the City responsible for unsold commercial inventory unless deliberately approved.

50.158Pre-Order Model

A pre-committed purchase model may reduce risk.

50.159Canadian Suppliers

The program can prioritize identifying Canadian suppliers where lawful and useful.

50.160Canadian Does Not Automatically Mean Cheapest

Show:

price;
quality;
lead time;
repairability.

50.161Foreign Supply Remains Possible

Canadian resilience is not autarky.

Use the best responsible supply option.

50.162Supplier Diversity

A second source can have value even if slightly more expensive.

Risk reduction matters.

50.163No Supplier Favouritism

Canadian supplier identification should not become:

preferred-friend procurement.

50.164Pooling Procurement Rules

If the City buys on behalf of businesses:

Obtain legal and procurement review.

A different model may be better:

businesses collectively buy independently.

50.165City as Facilitator

The City may simply:

convene;
provide neutral information;

rather than handle every transaction.

50.166Independent Cooperative

If pooling becomes successful:

An independent cooperative or business organization may be a more natural operator.

50.167Final Pooling Status

By Year Four:

Independent

Limited City Facilitation

Stopped

No endless pilot.

50.168Enthusiast Economy

The Enthusiast Economy should measure whether specialized interests create:

real participation;
services;
businesses;
repair;
events;
skills.

50.169Enthusiast Does Not Mean Hobby Only

Examples could include communities around:

outdoor recreation;
automotive;
cycling;
making;
repair;
gaming;
crafts;
specialized technology.

Do not prescribe the interests.

50.170Community Reveals the Categories

Use local demand.

50.171Gap Mapping

Ask:

What activity do residents regularly leave Owen Sound to buy, repair, learn or participate in?

That can reveal opportunities.

50.172Gap Is Opportunity, Not City Mandate

The City can share the information.

Entrepreneurs decide whether to act.

50.173Enthusiast Directory

Possible public information:

clubs;
businesses;
repair services;
events;
training.

Use neutral inclusion standards.

50.174Repair Economy

Repair is particularly useful because it may:

keep spending local;
extend product life;
develop skills;
improve resilience.

50.175Repair Business Count

Track relevant businesses where reliably known.

50.176Repair Capacity

Better measure:

Which commonly needed repairs can residents and businesses now obtain locally that were difficult before?

50.177No Self-Sufficiency Score

Do not pretend Owen Sound should locally produce or repair everything.

50.178Maker Economy

Track:

spaces;
programs;
businesses;
training;

where genuine activity exists.

50.179City-Owned Maker Space

Do not build one merely because:

maker economy sounds innovative.

Use existing:

school;
private;
library;
community;

capacity first.

50.180Partnership Before Program

Applies here.

50.181Events

Enthusiast events can attract visitors and strengthen local activity.

Measure:

participation;
cost;
local operator feedback.

Do not invent economic-impact multipliers.

50.182Training

Local skills programs may support:

business;
employment;
repair.

Cross-reference Civic Corps and partnerships.

50.183Youth

Young people can participate in:

maker;
repair;
business;

training.

Paid work remains paid.

50.184No Free Labour for Businesses

A youth program should not become unpaid labour replacing normal paid positions.

50.185Entrepreneurship Education

The City may connect young people with:

mentors;
business organizations.

It should not guarantee business success.

50.186Local Procurement

City procurement is one of the strongest business measures the municipality directly controls.

50.187Vendor Gateway

Track participation in the Local Vendor Gateway.

50.188Vendor Count

Show:

registered vendors;
active bidders.

A large registration number alone is weak.

50.189Local Vendor Participation

Possible measure:

percentage of eligible competitive opportunities receiving at least one qualified local bid.

This measures access.

Not favoritism.

50.190No Local Win Quota by Default

The goal is:

fair opportunity.

Contracts still follow applicable procurement rules.

The City may report what portion of eligible spending went to local suppliers.

Use it descriptively.

Do not automatically set a legal or policy quota without review.

Likewise.

A contract must still deliver:

value;
performance.

50.194Procurement Competition

Track:

bids per opportunity;

where meaningful.

50.195One Bid

Repeated single-bid procurements should trigger review.

50.196One Bid Is Not Automatically Corruption

Specialized markets can legitimately produce few bidders.

Investigate.

50.197Small Contract Access

Review whether smaller businesses can compete for appropriately sized work.

50.198No Artificial Contract Splitting

Do not divide contracts improperly just to:

favour local suppliers.

50.199Quick Quote

If a lawful Quick Quote process is adopted for low-value procurement:

Track:

use;
competition;
cycle time.

50.200Quick Does Not Mean Closed Club

Ensure new suppliers can participate.

50.201Procurement Forecast

Publish upcoming opportunities where appropriate.

This gives small firms time to prepare.

50.202Forecast Is Not Promise

Procurement needs can change.

Label:

planned.

50.203Vendor Education

Offer simple information about:

how City purchasing works;
insurance;
bid requirements.

50.204Do Not Coach One Bidder Privately

Provide equal public information.

50.205Bid Complexity

Review whether small procurements require unnecessarily complex paperwork.

50.206Safety and Insurance Remain

Do not remove legitimate protections.

50.207Repair Before Replace

Municipal procurement can support the repair economy.

Track significant cases where:

repair;
refurbishment;

was evaluated before replacement.

50.208Repair Saving

Only claim actual savings after:

repair cost;
expected remaining life;
future maintenance;

are considered.

50.209Canadian Capacity Screen

For selected critical procurements:

Ask whether there are:

Canadian;
regional;
local;

options.

50.210Canadian Is One Factor

Also consider:

value;
quality;
compliance;
supply security.

50.211Supplier Concentration

Track high-risk categories dependent on:

one supplier.

50.212Local Supplier Development

Do not promise contracts.

The City can explain upcoming needs so businesses can decide whether to build capacity.

50.213Procurement Feedback

Businesses should be able to say:

process too complex;
specification unfair;
communication unclear.

50.214Bidder Feedback

Where appropriate:

Offer debriefing according to procurement policy.

50.215Complaint Process

Procurement complaints should follow:

formal;
neutral;

process.

Not mayoral intervention.

50.216No Campaign Procurement

Political support is irrelevant.

50.217No Opponent Penalty

Political criticism is irrelevant.

50.218Business Incentives

Any municipal incentive should appear in the Scorecard.

50.219Incentive Types

Possible:

grant;
fee relief;
land;
tax-related program;
infrastructure contribution.

50.220Complete Public Contribution

Show material value.

50.221Incentive Approval

Not the same as:

project completed.

50.222Incentive Completion

Track whether the recipient delivered the agreed public benefit.

50.223Clawback

Where lawful and included in the agreement:

Use remedies if commitments are not met.

50.224No Favourite Business

Incentives require:

neutral;
lawful;

criteria.

50.225Incentive Evaluation

Ask:

What public purpose?

What public contribution?

What did the business deliver?

Would the project likely have occurred anyway?

The last question may be difficult.

Do not pretend certainty.

50.226Public Land

If land is sold or leased for economic development:

Use proper valuation and disclosure.

50.227Discounted Land

A discount is a subsidy.

Show it.

50.228Jobs Commitment

If an agreement includes jobs:

Define:

number;
duration;
measurement.

50.229No Job Estimate as Job Delivered

Separate:

promised

from

verified.

50.230Privacy

Do not require private payroll data beyond what is necessary for an agreement.

50.231Commercial Development

Track:

major applications;
permits;
occupancy;

similarly to housing.

50.232Approved Commercial Space Is Not Operating Business

Same anti-gaming rule.

50.233Occupancy

A building reaching occupancy does not guarantee:

tenant;
commercial success.

Track stage accurately.

50.234Development Processing Time

Use Section 46 methods.

50.235City-Controlled Delay

Report.

50.236Applicant Delay

Report separately.

50.237Outside Agency

Report separately.

50.238One Business File

Complex businesses should have a coordinated municipal file.

50.239File Owner

One lead.

50.240No Mayor Case Manager

The Mayor should not personally manage ordinary business applications.

50.241Equal Queue

Connected businesses do not move ahead.

50.242Major Employer

A major employer may deserve senior administrative coordination because of:

complexity;
public consequence.

That is different from:

preferential legal treatment.

50.243Economic Emergency

If a major employer announces closure:

The City may coordinate response.

Do not promise to rescue the private company automatically.

50.244Business Retention

Track significant business-retention files where City action was relevant.

50.245Retention Is Hard to Attribute

Do not claim:

City saved 200 jobs

unless evidence is exceptionally clear.

Better:

City resolved a municipal infrastructure issue affecting the employer.

50.246Business Recruitment

Likewise.

50.247Announcement Is Not Arrival

A company announcing interest is not:

an operating business.

50.248Signed Agreement Is Not Operating

Track stages.

50.249Open for Business

Count operating status when appropriate.

50.250Major Employer Departure

Report accurately.

Do not hide it from the economic scorecard.

50.251No Mayor Blame for Every Closure

External conditions matter.

50.252No Mayor Credit for Every Opening

Same principle.

50.253Business Support Partners

The City should map existing organizations before creating programs.

50.254Partnership Before Program

Use:

business centres;
educational institutions;
chambers or associations;
other capable organizations;

where appropriate.

50.255Do Not Duplicate Advice

If another organization provides high-quality:

business planning;
mentoring;

the City does not need to recreate it.

50.256Municipal Specialty

City Hall should concentrate on:

municipal navigation;
local infrastructure;
public realm;
procurement;
local policy.

50.257Referral Quality

Track whether Start-Up Desk referrals reach the correct outside business-support partner.

50.258Partner Capacity

Do not promise:

grants;
mentorship;

the partner has not confirmed.

50.259Shared Business Desk

Where Grey County or another partner shares service:

Measure the resident journey.

50.260No Wrong Government

A business owner should not be bounced between:

City;
County;

without help.

50.261Planning Handoff

If planning roles are shared:

Make the business-facing process clear.

50.262Business Education

Short public sessions may cover:

starting;
permits;
procurement;
digital safety;
Canadian sourcing.

Measure attendance lightly.

50.263Attendance Is Not Business Creation

A workshop participant is not:

new business.

50.264Useful Outcome

Ask whether attendees:

understood the next step.

50.265Mentorship

The City can connect.

Mentors should not become municipal gatekeepers.

50.266Volunteer Mentors

Respect:

conflict;
confidentiality.

50.267No Investor Matching Guarantee

The City should not imply investments are:

safe;
endorsed.

50.268Business Financing

Provide verified referrals.

Do not act as lender unless expressly authorized and justified under a separate program.

50.269Federal and Provincial Programs

Verify current status before publishing.

50.270Program Date

Every external program listing should say:

Verified as of [date].

50.271Stale Grant

Archive quickly.

50.272Grant Application Help

The City may help explain the program.

Do not promise approval.

50.273Business Data

Collect minimally.

50.274Directory Data

Basic public business information may be appropriate.

50.275Financial Data

Private:

revenue;
profit;
payroll;

should generally not be collected for ordinary scorecard purposes.

50.276Customer Data

Shop Local programs should not produce municipal customer dossiers.

50.277Purchase History

Avoid collecting unless truly necessary for a voluntary reward transaction.

50.278Aggregation

Use aggregate program data.

50.279No Political Profiling

Never combine:

business participation;
municipal consultation;
political opinion.

50.280Business Contact Lists

A City business contact list must not become:

campaign list.

50.281Commercial Confidentiality

Protect:

proprietary;
negotiating;

information appropriately.

50.282Open Books Still Apply to Public Money

If a business receives public funds:

The public contribution and agreed public benefit should be visible where law permits.

50.283Privacy Is Not Secrecy for Subsidy

Do not hide:

public grant;

behind generic claims of confidentiality without legal basis.

50.284Business Map

A public directory may map business locations.

50.285No Performance Heatmap

Do not publish:

"weak business";
"low sales";

maps.

50.286Hours and Status

Allow businesses to update:

open;
closed;
moved.

50.287Public Correction

Provide a simple correction process.

50.288Digital Independence

Business-facing City services should not depend on one proprietary platform unnecessarily.

50.289Export

Business directory data should be exportable where lawful.

50.290No Platform Lock-In

If a vendor contract ends:

The City should keep:

its public business information.

AI may help answer routine municipal questions.

50.292AI Accuracy

Sample answers regularly.

50.293No AI Permit Approval by Default

Formal decisions remain with authorized processes.

50.294Human Escalation

Always available for complex business matters.

50.295AI Source

An AI business assistant should cite or point to the official City requirement where appropriate.

50.296Wrong Answer

Track significant AI errors.

Fix or disable.

50.297Commercial Advice Boundary

AI should not present:

investment;
legal;
accounting;

advice as City authority.

50.298Business Resilience

The Scorecard should include a practical resilience component.

50.299Supplier Risk

Business workshops or pooling programs may identify critical supply gaps.

50.300Canadian Capacity

Track real cases where businesses found:

Canadian;
regional;

alternatives.

50.301Do Not Count Search Result as Supplier Conversion

A supplier identified is not necessarily:

used.

50.302Supplier Adoption

Where businesses voluntarily report:

actual purchasing change;

aggregate the result.

50.303Repairability

Promote awareness of:

local repair services.

Measure directory activity cautiously.

50.304Emergency Business Continuity

Local business resilience can intersect with:

power;
communication;
emergency planning.

The City can provide preparedness information.

50.305City Does Not Guarantee Continuity

Businesses still manage their own operations.

50.306Public Infrastructure Reliability

Business experience should cross-reference:

roads;
water;
downtown;
digital public systems.

50.307Construction Impact

Major municipal construction can materially affect businesses.

50.308Advance Notice

Measure whether affected businesses received reasonable notice where possible.

50.309Access Plan

Major projects should identify:

customer;
delivery;
emergency;

access.

50.310Construction Delay

Do not promise zero impact.

50.311Business Feedback After Construction

Ask:

communication;
access;
lessons.

50.312No Automatic Compensation

Follow law and policy.

50.313Downtown Business

Cross-reference Section 48.

50.314Upper Floors

Cross-reference Section 49.

50.315Enthusiast Economy

Keep broader specialized-business activity here.

50.316Tourism

Cross-reference event and recreation metrics.

50.317Youth Entrepreneurship

Cross-reference Civic Corps.

50.318Canadian Procurement

Cross-reference Section 11 and Section 44.

50.319Avoid Double Counting

A local business winning a City contract can appear:

in procurement;
in business;

but the city-wide final scorecard should not add it twice as two separate economic outcomes.

50.320Business Scorecard Table

A headline table could use:

Measure

Baseline

Current

Target / Standard

Trend

Status

Owner

Possible rows:

Start-Up Desk response;
ten-day compliance;
fee waivers;
red-tape items resolved;
openings;
closures;
expansions;
local vendor participation;
procurement competition;
Shop Local participation;
Penny status;
pooling savings;
delivery status;
business satisfaction.

50.321Start-Up Desk Table

Measure

Current Quarter

Year to Date

Standard

Trend

50.322Red Tape Table

Barrier

City-Controlled?

Status

Action

Result

50.323Business Activity Table

Measure

Baseline

Current

Change

Data Limitation

Possible:

openings;
closures;
relocations;
permit activity.

50.324Procurement Access Table

Measure

Baseline

Current

Trend

Possible:

registered vendors;
local bidders;
average bids;
low-value quote competition.

50.325Shop Local Table

Program

Participants

Public Cost

Measured Benefit

Status

50.326Penny Table

Measure

Current

Target / Rule

Possible:

rewards issued;
redeemed;
outstanding liability;
program cost;
participating merchants;
confirmed fraud loss.

50.327Pooling Table

Category

Participants

Baseline Cost

Pooled Cost

Verified Saving

Status

50.328Delivery Table

Measure

Current

Possible:

businesses;
deliveries;
cost per delivery;
user charge;
public subsidy;
failed deliveries.

50.329Canadian Capacity Table

Category

Canadian Alternative Identified

Adopted by Participants

Note

Do not overstate completeness.

50.330Traffic Lights

Green

Meeting adopted municipal standard.

Amber

Material barrier or pilot question.

Red

Significant municipal corrective action required.

Grey

Data insufficient or primarily outside City control.

50.331Green Business Openings

Do not automatically mark:

openings up;

as Green municipal performance.

They are economic context.

50.332Red Closure Rate

Likewise:

Do not automatically mark closures as City failure.

50.333City-Controlled Metrics Receive Status

Service and municipal-process metrics can use direct performance status more confidently.

50.334External Context May Use Trend Only

For:

interest;
broader unemployment;
inflation;

trend may be more appropriate than Red/Green.

50.335Anti-Gaming Rule One

Do not count Start-Up Desk inquiries as businesses created.

50.336Anti-Gaming Rule Two

Do not count people attending a workshop as businesses created.

50.337Anti-Gaming Rule Three

Do not count a business announcement as an operating business.

50.338Anti-Gaming Rule Four

Do not claim every opening resulted from City policy.

50.339Anti-Gaming Rule Five

Do not blame every closure on City policy.

50.340Anti-Gaming Rule Six

Do not call permit value:

private profit;
municipal investment.

50.341Anti-Gaming Rule Seven

Do not call an identified red-tape issue:

removed

until the process has actually changed.

50.342Anti-Gaming Rule Eight

Do not remove a public-safety requirement and call it efficiency without professional justification.

50.343Anti-Gaming Rule Nine

Do not stop the ten-day clock invisibly.

50.344Anti-Gaming Rule Ten

Do not improve ten-day compliance by excluding difficult files without publishing the exclusion.

50.345Anti-Gaming Rule Eleven

Do not count a fee waiver as business subsidy twice.

50.346Anti-Gaming Rule Twelve

Do not count a directory listing as business participation in every Shop Local program.

50.347Anti-Gaming Rule Thirteen

Do not count Penny rewards issued as actual consumer spending.

50.348Anti-Gaming Rule Fourteen

Do not ignore outstanding Penny liability.

50.349Anti-Gaming Rule Fifteen

Do not call generic payment-processing assumptions verified savings.

50.350Anti-Gaming Rule Sixteen

Do not call local delivery successful solely because delivery volume is high if subsidy is unsustainable.

50.351Anti-Gaming Rule Seventeen

Do not call pooled purchasing cheaper until:

freight;
administration;

are included.

50.352Anti-Gaming Rule Eighteen

Do not call a Canadian supplier alternative a successful switch unless it is actually used.

50.353Anti-Gaming Rule Nineteen

Do not call local procurement successful simply because local award value increased.

Competition and value still matter.

50.354Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty

Do not split contracts improperly to inflate local awards.

50.355Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty-One

Do not count public incentives as business investment.

50.356Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty-Two

Do not count promised jobs as verified jobs.

50.357Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty-Three

Do not count private business contact information as campaign data.

50.358Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty-Four

Do not change the definition of:

local

before election reporting.

50.359Anti-Gaming Rule Twenty-Five

Do not cherry-pick only thriving businesses for satisfaction surveys.

50.360Baseline

Year One should establish:

Start-Up Desk volume;
service time;
municipal barriers;
openings and closures where measurable;
procurement participation;
Shop Local participation;
local supplier capacity;
business satisfaction.

50.361Unknown Baseline

Where previous data was not collected:

Say:

Not previously measured.

50.362No Historical Reconstruction From Anecdote

Do not invent:

business-opening history;

from memory.

50.363Year One Objective

Make municipal business navigation clear and test the first business pilots.

50.364Year Two Objective

Scale the service improvements that actually reduced friction.

50.365Year Three Objective

Institutionalize successful procurement, Shop Local and local-capacity reforms.

50.366Year Four Objective

Publish the full business record and ensure programs survive, transfer or stop responsibly.

50.367Four-Year Core Measures

Strong candidates:

meaningful Start-Up Desk response;
ten-day compliance;
fee waivers;
red-tape reforms completed;
municipal processing;
local supplier bid participation;
procurement competition;
business satisfaction;
Shop Local participation;
Penny financial sustainability;
pooled purchasing verified savings;
local delivery sustainability;
Canadian supplier adoption;
commercial reinvestment.

50.368Business Openings Four-Year Trend

Show if reliable.

Do not assign automatic causation.

50.369Business Closures Four-Year Trend

Same.

50.370Net Business Count

Where reliable:

Show:

openings;
closures;
net.

Do not imply net count equals economic quality.

50.371A Few Strong Employers

One major employer can matter more than:

many tiny registrations.

Use multiple measures.

50.372Small Business Still Matters

Do not make major-employer recruitment the only strategy.

A diverse local economy adds resilience.

50.373Home Business Still Matters

Include where measurable.

50.374Repair Business Still Matters

Include where meaningful.

50.375Entrepreneurship Is Not Only Start-Ups

Existing-business expansion may be the strongest result.

50.376Four-Year Business Audit

At term end publish:

Start-Up Desk use

service standards

fee waivers

municipal barriers removed

municipal barriers retained

business openings

closures

expansions

procurement access

local vendor participation

Shop Local

Penny

delivery

pooling

Canadian supply

incentives

business satisfaction

major unresolved business barriers

50.377Name the Biggest Municipal Business Improvement

Use evidence.

50.378Name the Biggest Municipal Business Failure

Use evidence.

50.379Name the Most Common Start-Up Barrier

Say whether it is:

municipal;
provincial;
financial;
market.

50.380Name the Largest Red-Tape Reform

Show:

old process;
new process;
result.

50.381Name a Rule That Was Reviewed and Kept

Explain why.

This proves red-tape review is not simply deregulation.

50.382Name the Best Procurement Improvement

Show:

competition;
access;
value.

50.383Name the Shop Local Program That Worked Best

Use data.

50.384Name a Shop Local Program That Was Stopped

If applicable.

50.385Name the Penny Result

By the end of the term:

No ambiguity.

50.386Name the Delivery Result

Likewise.

50.387Name the Pooling Result

Likewise.

50.388Name the Canadian Capacity Result

Use actual supplier adoption.

50.389Name the Best Enthusiast-Economy Opportunity

Show what actually developed.

50.390Name the Biggest Business Constraint the City Could Not Solve

Important.

50.391Start-Up Desk Test

Ask:

Could a new entrepreneur get a clear municipal answer faster and with fewer handoffs than four years earlier?

50.392Before You Sign Test

Ask:

Did more prospective business owners learn municipal constraints before making expensive commitments?

50.393Red Tape Test

Ask:

Did the City remove requirements that lacked a sufficient public purpose while preserving necessary protections?

50.394Procurement Test

Ask:

Did more local and Canadian suppliers have a fair chance to compete without sacrificing value or fairness?

50.395Shop Local Test

Ask:

Did Shop Local programs create measurable value greater than their public cost?

50.396Penny Test

Ask:

Did the Penny function as a sustainable voluntary reward program without becoming currency, unfunded liability or resident-tracking system?

50.397Delivery Test

Ask:

Did the service solve a real gap better than existing private alternatives?

50.398Pooling Test

Ask:

Did businesses actually pay less after shipping and administration?

50.399Canadian Capacity Test

Ask:

Did businesses gain practical Canadian supply options, not merely a directory of possibilities?

50.400Enthusiast Economy Test

Ask:

Did specialized local interests translate into real businesses, services, repair, skills or events?

50.401Business Activity Test

Ask:

Did the City report openings and closures honestly without turning normal economic change into political propaganda?

50.402Business Satisfaction Test

Ask:

Did businesses report clearer and more predictable City processes?

50.403Fairness Test

Ask:

Would a business critical of Council receive the same municipal treatment as a supporter?

The answer must be:

Yes.

50.404Privacy Test

Ask:

Did business programs operate without building unnecessary customer or merchant behavioural profiles?

50.405Institution Test

Ask:

Would the Start-Up Desk, Vendor Gateway and any successful Shop Local systems still work if the Mayor changed tomorrow?

50.406What Success Looks Like

Business success does not mean:

government claims every new store;
no business closes;
every entrepreneur receives a yes;
City Hall creates a municipal marketplace;
every purchase stays local.

Success means:

entrepreneurs know where to start;
municipal requirements are clearer;
incompatible sites are identified earlier;
City-controlled processing is measured;
unnecessary process is removed;
safety requirements remain;
local vendors can see opportunities;
procurement remains fair;
Shop Local programs prove their value or stop;
the Penny is transparent and financially real if it survives;
delivery exists only if a real gap exists;
pooled purchasing demonstrates actual net savings;
Canadian alternatives are identified practically;
enthusiasts and repair communities can grow organically;
public subsidies are visible;
business criticism does not affect City treatment;
economic claims remain modest enough to be true.

50.407What Failure Looks Like

Failure includes:

counting inquiries as businesses created;
boasting about response time while applications remain unresolved;
moving the service clock;
calling legitimate safety requirements red tape;
claiming every new business as a City success;
blaming City Hall for every closure;
favouring connected businesses;
using public directories as paid-ranking systems;
forcing businesses onto a Mayor-associated platform;
creating an unfunded Penny liability;
tracking resident purchases unnecessarily;
launching municipal delivery where private options already work;
operating an indefinite subsidized delivery system without public value;
claiming pooling savings before shipping and administration;
calling a supplier list Canadian independence without actual adoption;
designing procurement to predetermine local winners;
hiding public subsidies;
using business contact information for political campaigning;
entering Year Four with pilots that still have no final governance decision.

50.408The Business Scorecard Commitment

Owen Sound should commit to:

Measure whether it is becoming easier to understand and do lawful business in the City.

Separate municipal performance from broader economic conditions.

Treat the Start-Up Desk as a navigation service rather than a business-creation machine.

Give entrepreneurs one clear place to begin.

Coordinate multiple municipal requirements without pretending one office can erase lawful approvals.

Use Before You Sign to identify municipal constraints before entrepreneurs make avoidable expensive commitments.

Never present municipal navigation as legal, accounting or investment advice.

Measure early clarity as a business-service success.

Recognize that an early honest no can be better than a late ambiguous maybe.

Define the proposed ten-business-day standard precisely before measuring it.

Never represent the standard as a guarantee that every business will be open within ten days.

Define eligible files, clock start, clock stop and legitimate pauses.

Never hide municipal delay inside an applicant-delay category.

Publish ten-business-day performance where adopted.

Publish every eligible fee waiver triggered by a missed City service guarantee.

Never pressure staff to approve unsafe or incomplete work to protect the service metric.

Survey businesses about clarity, consistency and timeliness rather than approval outcomes.

Maintain a public Red Tape Log.

Distinguish unnecessary municipal requirements from legitimate public-safety protections.

Publish whether a reviewed requirement was removed, simplified, retained or outside City authority.

Explain why important retained rules remain.

Reduce duplicate business forms and repeated information requests where lawful.

Measure real processing improvement rather than form-edit counts.

Treat recurring applicant errors as a possible service-design problem.

Track business openings and closures only where the underlying data is reliable.

Distinguish opening, relocation, expansion and closure.

Never claim every opening as a City-created business.

Never claim every closure as municipal policy failure.

Never claim jobs created without evidence.

Use employment, interest-rate and national economic data as context rather than City-controlled performance.

Track commercial investment using correct permit terminology.

Never confuse construction value with profit or municipal investment.

Do not use promotional economic-impact multipliers without credible methodology.

Survey existing businesses as well as start-ups.

Provide anonymous routes for municipal criticism.

Never retaliate against a business because it criticized the Mayor, Council or City policy.

Publish business-survey response counts and limitations.

Avoid invite-only business consultation clubs.

Recognize home-based businesses as legitimate economic activity where lawful.

Tailor industrial and manufacturing navigation to real servicing and transportation needs.

Never describe land as shovel ready without evidence.

Keep regional tourism statistics separate from downtown or Owen Sound-only economic claims.

Measure Shop Local programs independently rather than assuming they work because the idea sounds appealing.

Keep Shop Local participation voluntary.

Respect resident freedom to buy where they choose.

Define Local clearly for each program.

Recognize the difference between locally owned and locally located businesses.

Provide neutral basic business-directory access.

Do not sell basic municipal ranking.

Label any sponsored promotion clearly if it exists.

Allow businesses to correct directory information.

Remove stale listings.

Never treat a directory listing as a City endorsement of a business.

Keep search and listing rules politically neutral.

Never force businesses onto map.ca or another private platform to obtain ordinary municipal visibility.

Verify current payment-processing information before making cost claims.

Allow businesses and customers to choose lawful payment methods.

Never shame people for payment choice.

Measure any debit-focused pilot using actual participating-business evidence.

Never calculate business savings using generic payment assumptions alone.

Keep the Penny a voluntary reward program rather than currency.

Never describe the Penny as legal tender or a replacement for Canadian dollars.

Identify the Penny's real funding before issuing rewards.

Never issue unfunded reward obligations.

Track outstanding Penny liability.

Track redemption honestly.

Publish Penny administration, technology, reward and fraud costs.

Do not claim Penny sales impacts without evidence.

Do not turn a loyalty program into a resident purchase-tracking system.

Never connect Penny data to political data.

Define the Penny wind-down process before launch.

Honour legitimate participant balances if the program closes.

Give the Penny a final Scale, Maintain, Transfer, Modify or Stop decision.

Test whether a local-delivery gap actually exists before creating a program.

Map existing private delivery providers first.

Start any delivery pilot small.

Publish cost per delivery and public subsidy.

Never call publicly subsidized delivery free.

Prefer a capable private or community operator where one can sustainably provide the service.

Do not subsidize a municipal competitor against functioning local delivery companies without a strong public-interest case.

Stop delivery pilots that do not justify their cost.

Test pooled purchasing narrowly before expansion.

Keep business participation voluntary.

Use a real baseline before claiming purchasing savings.

Include shipping and administration in pooled-cost calculations.

Avoid creating City-owned commercial inventory risk.

Identify Canadian suppliers where this strengthens local resilience.

Do not assume Canadian supply is automatically cheapest or automatically safest.

Consider price, quality, lead time, repairability and supply concentration.

Do not turn Canadian sourcing into supplier favouritism.

Obtain legal and procurement review if the City would purchase goods on behalf of private businesses.

Prefer facilitation over municipal wholesale operations where appropriate.

Allow successful pooling to move into independent business or cooperative governance.

Bring Community Pooling to a clear final status by the end of the term.

Use the Enthusiast Economy to identify organic local demand rather than centrally choose hobbies for residents.

Map local repair, maker, club and specialized-business capacity where useful.

Treat identified consumer gaps as entrepreneurial opportunities rather than automatic municipal programs.

Measure actual repair capacity rather than directory entries alone.

Never pretend Owen Sound must produce or repair everything locally.

Use existing schools, libraries, businesses and community organizations before constructing a City maker facility.

Apply Partnership Before Program.

Measure enthusiast events honestly without unsupported economic-impact claims.

Connect youth to entrepreneurship and technical skills without replacing paid private employment with free labour.

Use City procurement as a major measurable opportunity for local business access.

Track registered vendors and actual bidders separately.

Measure whether eligible competitive opportunities attract qualified local bids.

Never guarantee local suppliers a City contract.

Report local award share descriptively rather than treating it as an automatic performance grade.

Measure procurement competition.

Review repeated one-bid procurements.

Do not assume one bid proves wrongdoing.

Make appropriately sized contracts accessible to smaller businesses without improperly splitting purchases.

Use Quick Quote processes only within lawful procurement rules.

Keep Quick Quote open to new suppliers.

Publish appropriate procurement forecasts.

Provide equal vendor education about City requirements.

Never coach a preferred bidder privately.

Simplify unnecessary bid paperwork while preserving insurance, safety and legal protections.

Consider repair before replacement where lifecycle value supports it.

Do not claim repair savings without considering remaining asset life.

Apply a Canadian Capacity Screen to selected critical procurement.

Monitor dangerous single-supplier dependence.

Provide businesses advance information about future City needs without promising contracts.

Offer fair bidder feedback and complaint routes.

Never use procurement to reward supporters or punish critics.

Publish the full municipal value of business incentives.

Track incentives from approval through delivery of the promised public benefit.

Use lawful clawbacks or remedies where agreements provide them.

Never favour a business because of political connection.

Treat discounted municipal land as a real subsidy.

Distinguish promised jobs from verified jobs.

Collect only the private business information necessary to verify a public agreement.

Track commercial-development stages accurately.

Never count approved commercial space as an operating business.

Measure City-controlled commercial-processing delay separately from applicant and outside-agency delay.

Give complex business files one municipal coordinating lead.

Do not turn the Mayor into the case manager for ordinary applications.

Maintain equal queue rules.

Coordinate significant employers professionally without giving them exemption from law.

Report major business-retention and recruitment files cautiously.

Do not claim jobs saved or created unless evidence is strong.

Treat business announcements, signed agreements and actual operation as separate stages.

Use capable external business-support organizations rather than duplicating them unnecessarily.

Concentrate City Hall on the functions only City Hall can perform well.

Apply No Wrong Door between Owen Sound, Grey County and other business-support bodies.

Verify every outside grant, loan or support program before publishing it.

Date every external business-program listing.

Do not promise approval from another government or lender.

Collect minimal business data.

Do not build municipal profiles of business revenue, profit, payroll or customers for ordinary scorecard purposes.

Never use municipal business contact lists for a political campaign.

Protect legitimate commercial confidentiality while keeping public subsidies transparent.

Do not map private business weakness or sales performance.

Maintain export and exit capability for public business-directory data.

Do not create private-platform lock-in.

Use AI for routine business navigation only when its accuracy is tested.

Keep formal municipal decisions with authorized people and processes.

Always provide human escalation for complex business matters.

Do not let a City AI system drift into legal, accounting or investment advice.

Track practical business-resilience improvements such as real supplier alternatives and repair capacity.

Do not count a supplier identified as a supplier adopted.

Help businesses prepare for emergencies without pretending the City can guarantee private continuity.

Give affected businesses reasonable notice of major municipal construction where possible.

Maintain access and delivery plans during significant public works.

Ask businesses what could improve after major construction.

Cross-reference downtown, housing, infrastructure, youth and procurement outcomes without double counting.

Publish clear Start-Up Desk, Red Tape, Procurement, Shop Local, Penny, Pooling and Delivery tables.

Use Green, Amber, Red and Grey primarily for areas where the City has meaningful control.

Do not mark broader economic conditions as City failure or success without context.

Never count workshop attendance as businesses created.

Never count announcements as operating businesses.

Never change the definition of Local for election-year reporting.

Never cherry-pick successful businesses for surveys.

Use Year One to establish the baseline and test pilots.

Use Year Two to scale service reforms that reduce actual friction.

Use Year Three to institutionalize strong procurement, Shop Local and Canadian-capacity tools.

Use Year Four to bring every major business pilot to a permanent, independent or stopped status.

Publish the full four-year Business Audit.

Name the biggest municipal business improvement.

Name the biggest municipal business failure.

Name the most common municipal barrier.

Name one rule that was removed and one that was kept.

Name the final Penny decision.

Name the final local-delivery decision.

Name the final Community Pooling decision.

Name the strongest Canadian supplier result.

Name the most promising enthusiast-economy opportunity.

Name the biggest business constraint outside municipal control.

Judge the final record by whether lawful business became easier to navigate, not by how many economic press releases City Hall produced.

A strong Business Scorecard should allow a local entrepreneur to say:

I knew where to start.

I knew what the City required.

I knew how long the municipal part should take.

I knew what I needed before I signed a lease.

I received the same treatment as everyone else.

If the City missed its own standard, that was visible.

It should also allow taxpayers to ask:

Did the Penny actually work?

What did it cost?

Did delivery solve a real problem?

Did pooled purchasing actually save money?

Did Canadian sourcing produce real alternatives?

Can local businesses compete for City work fairly?

Did the City remove unnecessary process?

Did it preserve important protections?

Are businesses opening and expanding?

Are businesses closing?

What part of that is actually connected to City policy?

Government should be confident enough to answer the last question with:

Sometimes very little.

That honesty strengthens the parts the City genuinely controls.

Make the rules clear. Answer faster. Say no early when necessary. Remove process that has no public purpose. Protect the rules that do. Give local businesses a fair chance. Test every Shop Local idea. Keep what works. Stop what does not. Never confuse private entrepreneurship with government accomplishment.

← Chapter 49: Housing: The Public Housing Scorecard Chapter 51: Safety: The Public Safety Scorecard →